by: Defenders of Wildlife: Kassandra Kelly Posted on: December 12, 2012
Photo: Great Blue Heron in flight over wetland home in Oregon. Steve Hillebrand, courtesy of USFWS.
Editor’s Note: This piece is written from the perspective that monetizing species or wetlands through the creation of species or wetland banks is a solution to declining habitat and biodiversity. This is one way the EPA currently implements its regulation of wetlands. A given success story saw a wastewater company planting trees to cool water released from its treatment plant, rather than paying for expensive cooling towers.
You may have heard about payments for ecosystem services. Whether regulated or voluntary, bundled or stacked, market issuing credits or shares or offsets… any discussion about ecosystem services can get geekified real fast. You may even ask, eyes glazing over and finger hovering over the click button, what’s in this for me?
In a word: payment. Imagine paying land mangers to manage their land in a way that provides benefits to the community. Interested? Read on.
What are ecosystem services?
An ecosystem service is a function the earth naturally provides for society. For example, trees give us oxygen and shade, forests purify our drinking water, and wetlands filter our wastewater. As a society, we value clean air, water, fish and wildlife and natural landscapes. In many instances, we have regulations that constrain activities that are harmful to the environment, like discharging toxic chemicals, destroying endangered species habitat and catching fish beyond a legal limit. Although these regulations are effective at limiting harmful acts, they are not always helpful in establishing positive or restorative actions. Enter the marketplace.
Let’s purchase a Great Blue Heron’s services.
An ecosystem marketplace provides incentives that create a win-win situation for both landowners and the environment. What’s the incentive? Money. An ecosystem market arises when people are voluntarily willing to pay to establish or enhance a particular natural function. For example, a developer wanting to build a new subdivision might voluntarily choose to meet air quality requirements by paying a nearby farmer to plant trees to absorb the greenhouse gases to be emitted over the lifespan of the project.
How do we put a price on nature?
Of course we can’t really buy a heron, nor attach a value to a lovely view. And payment for ecosystem services is not a new concept. Just look at the USDA’s Conservation Reserve Program, which helps landowners and farmers reduce soil erosion, improve water quality and quantity, support wildlife habitat, and reduce damages caused by floods and other natural disasters by paying farmers to preserve natural areas on their property. The Environmental Protection Agency wetland mitigation banks, which provide a place where wetlands can be bought and sold, are familiar tools for developers who choose or are forced to mitigate their impact on wetlands. But when it comes to those things that don’t have a price, such as oak woodlands and sagebrush country in Oregon or even the lowly coffin cave mold beetle in Texas, we need to find a way to measure the benefits they provide.
It’s a great idea but does it work?
If you are a landowner who wants to try out these new tools, you can find out by setting goals for restoring natural functions on your land (if they’ve been impacted), and then measuring progress toward those goals. For instance, fencing cows away from a creek and planting trees to shade the water. The result? Cool, healthy water for fish and wildlife, and a naturally functioning ecosystem.
Quant is short for Quantify.
Your inner accountant knows it can’t be that easy and she’s right. Buyers and sellers are a long ways from finding one another. And when they do, the benefits provided by healthy ecosystems need to be quantifiable so that everyone knows what they are getting. Remember your goal? Cool, healthy water. A transparent transaction between buyers and sellers requires a practical way to measure all the complexity in a functioning ecosystem, and a way to state in universal language whether you are progressing toward that goal.
See it in action:
Following are several great examples of work people are already doing on green infrastructure, endangered species banks, and new methods for measuring and quantifying conservation outcomes:
In 2003, Clean Water Services decided not to build multi-million dollar cooling towers for their wastewater treatment plants. They planted trees instead. In order to comply with the Clean Water Act, Oregon utility Clean Water Services worked with a volunteer committee comprised of local landowners, conservationists, nonprofits, and government agencies to enhance natural riparian areas along the Tualatin River so that warmer water released from the wastewater treatment plant would be cooled naturally, at minimal ratepayer cost.
Speciesbanking.com is a global information clearinghouse focusing on biodiversity offsetting, compensation and banking. There are over thirty species banks already at work, where credits are available to those who need to mitigate damage to environmental resources such as gopher tortoise habitat, giant garter snake habitat, and plenty of other endangered species whose habitats can be conserved effectively in other locations.
For further reading visit Marketplace for Nature portal in the Conservation Registry, which features information on projects currently underway; Willamette Partnership for information on quantifying
Leave a Reply
Articles On Ideas
Ideas: Lessons learned, perspectives, advice and more by and for organizers working toward a more democratic society.
- Jun 5 US Climate Movement: Funnel Money Downward if You Want to Survive
- Jan 12 For Teachers and Citizens: How to Respond to Federal Immigration Raids
- Jan 5 How To Respond When Your (Local) Government Gets Sued By A Corporation
- Dec 8 Occupy’s Not So Invisible Work
- Dec 8 Getting Specific About What We Want
- Dec 8 National Sovereignty At Stake
- Dec 8 Lessons Learned By A Federal Enforcer
- Dec 8 Sacred Democracy-The Marriage of the Ethical and the Moral
- Dec 8 A Briefing On The State-Owned Bank of North Dakota
- Nov 8 Politicizing a Social Worker
- Nov 8 Sacred Democracy-Enlightenment and Democracy
- Oct 8 The People Know Best, Should We Listen?
- Oct 8 Sacred Democracy-Democracy: a Work in Progress
- Oct 8 Dispatches from Denmark-Ærø
- Oct 8 Protect The Local Initiative Process-Why Support WA Initiative 517
- Oct 8 Questions for a County Council Could-Be
- Sep 8 A Brief Chat about Workers’ Rights
- Sep 8 Sacred Democracy-Glimmers of Empathy in the Shadows of History
- Aug 8 Native Resilience and Interethnic Cooperation: How Natives are adapting to climate change, and helping their non-Native neighbors follow suit
- Aug 8 Imagining a New Society: Comparisons from Iceland
- Aug 8 Sacred Democracy-Rites of Nature
- Jul 8 Sacred Democracy-The Beatitudes of Fairness
- Jul 8 Speaking With a ‘Fractivist’: Data Acquisition to Federal Exemptions
- Jul 8 Selections from the Public News Service-July 2013 (Audio)
- Jul 8 How the Declaration of Independence got Hijacked
- Jun 10 A Bright Future: Creative, Passionate Students at Class Academy in Portland Participate in Read the Dirt Environmental Writing Contest
- Jun 8 (Audio): Read the Dirt’s Coverage of the 2013 Public Interest Environmental Law Conference
- Jun 8 Sacred Democracy-Living Democracy as Spiritual Practice (Or Vice Versa)
- May 8 Sacred Democracy-The Moral Blueprint
- May 8 Transforming Faith
- Feb 25 Park Rangers to the Rescue
- Feb 11 Washington’s Renewables: An Introduction
- Dec 12 Species Banks
- Nov 23 Our Slaves
- Nov 17 NW Coal Ports: Voice your concerns, voice them loud!
- Nov 13 Meditations on our Future
- Nov 4 Book: Ecoliterate: How Educators Are Cultivating Emotional, Social, and Ecological Intelligence
- Oct 14 Equity, Environmental Justice, and Industrial Pollution in Portland
- Oct 8 Cities advising Counties?
- Sep 12 Talking with Washington State Legislators-Stanford
- Aug 26 Talking with Washington State Legislators-Pollet
- Aug 21 Help! I’m being Climate Changed!
- Jul 14 Questionnaire for the authors of: THE GOLDILOCKS PLANET The 4 Billion Year Story of Earth’s Climate-Oxford University Press
- Jun 17 Can City Planning Make Us Cooler, Healthier and Friendlier?
- Jun 11 The Results-2012
- Mar 25 Making Clean Local Energy Accessible Now (Part 1)
- Mar 8 Our Right To Know
- Jan 18 PROTECT ONLINE FREEDOM—READ THE DIRT DEPENDS ON IT!
- Dec 23 Talking About Our Nuclear Hazard
- Oct 28 Why make Mt. St. Helens a National Park?
- Oct 20 The Story behind the Book, A Great Aridness: Climate Change and the Future of the American Southwest
- Jun 23 McKibben Comments on Expansion of Coal Exports at Cherry Point (Whatcom County)
- Apr 3 WASTED POWER
- Dec 20 Meet Some Environmental Consultants
- Dec 5 Using Dirt to Teach
- Oct 21 The We, The I and The Dirt
- Oct 21 Turning Pollution Into Energy
- Oct 21 Orange and Green
- Oct 21 Election 2010: Talk with a WA State Supreme Court Candidate (Wiggins)
- Oct 21 Election 2010: Talk with a WA State Supreme Court Candidate (Chief Justice Madsen)
- Oct 20 Our Dirty Web Designer (Video)