The We, The I and The Dirt
by: Simon Davis-Cohen Posted on: October 21, 2010
There are numerous reasons for valuing dirt, water, air, flora and fauna. These reasons can be both selfish and selfless. The selfish motivation, which I will call the I, asks “how does this affect me?” The selfless motivation, which I will call the WE, does not distinguish between its interests and the interests of others. When it comes to caring for a forest, for example, there are both selfish and selfless reasons for doing so. The selfish I tends to view a forest as a resource, while the selfless WE merely loves it. The selfish and selfless motivations are both valid, both can be lead astray and both are concerned with the forest’s health.
The selfish I places its importance above the natural world. The I asks, “how does this forest affect me?” After deliberating, the wise I realizes that the forest is essential to humans’ happiness and health. Thus, the self-concerned I is inclined to promote healthy dirt, water, air, flora and fauna.
Unfortunately, our selfish tendency can be near-sighted or misguided, leading us to either act contrary to our long-term self-interest or not recognize a self-interest. Such a near-sighted or misguided I might overlook the importance of a forest, or not see the common ground it shares with the WE, a mistake the wise I would never make.
Then there is the WE, which like the I, can be wise or misguided. The WE is deeply connected to the natural world, but the misguided WE allows these beliefs to distance itself from the I.
When the WE ponders its place among the natural world it finds it difficult to distinguish between its interests and those of the dirt, water, air, flora and fauna. Thus the WE, like the I, makes the business of these essentials its own, but unlike the I, which does so because its interests are dependent on the forest, the WE does so because its interest is the forest.
The WE’s train of thought is reasonable, for it sees that we cannot separate ourselves from the natural world. But, like the I, it can also be near-sighted and act contrary to its true interests. Sometimes the WE paints its struggle as selfless, as in, for example, the act of “saving” a tree. This can prevent it from connecting with the I, which would ask, “how does this tree affect me?” Even though such a question can be answered quite simply, the WE’s occasional inability to do so tragically alienates itself from its old friend, the I.
Although the WE’s motivations for caring for the natural world are not selfish, it has a selfish-interest for doing so. And although the I’s initial motivations are not selfless, protecting a forest is. No matter how we approach our place in the natural world, we see that all paths lead to the dirt. And so at Read The Dirt we will not focus on what divides us. Instead we focus on the ground, where all paths lead.
Read The Dirt is concerned with humans’ well-being, actions and ideas. We are interested in what a forest does for humans, as well as humans’ role in the forest. Because we are the most powerful members of the natural world, we think our actions, ideas and conversations are quite relevant.
We are defined by how we use our power, so let us use it wisely.
4 Responses to “The We, The I and The Dirt”
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Articles On Ideas
Ideas: Lessons learned, perspectives, advice and more by and for organizers working toward a more democratic society.
- Jun 5 US Climate Movement: Funnel Money Downward if You Want to Survive
- Jan 12 For Teachers and Citizens: How to Respond to Federal Immigration Raids
- Jan 5 How To Respond When Your (Local) Government Gets Sued By A Corporation
- Dec 8 Occupy’s Not So Invisible Work
- Dec 8 Getting Specific About What We Want
- Dec 8 National Sovereignty At Stake
- Dec 8 Lessons Learned By A Federal Enforcer
- Dec 8 Sacred Democracy-The Marriage of the Ethical and the Moral
- Dec 8 A Briefing On The State-Owned Bank of North Dakota
- Nov 8 Politicizing a Social Worker
- Nov 8 Sacred Democracy-Enlightenment and Democracy
- Oct 8 The People Know Best, Should We Listen?
- Oct 8 Sacred Democracy-Democracy: a Work in Progress
- Oct 8 Dispatches from Denmark-Ærø
- Oct 8 Protect The Local Initiative Process-Why Support WA Initiative 517
- Oct 8 Questions for a County Council Could-Be
- Sep 8 A Brief Chat about Workers’ Rights
- Sep 8 Sacred Democracy-Glimmers of Empathy in the Shadows of History
- Aug 8 Native Resilience and Interethnic Cooperation: How Natives are adapting to climate change, and helping their non-Native neighbors follow suit
- Aug 8 Imagining a New Society: Comparisons from Iceland
- Aug 8 Sacred Democracy-Rites of Nature
- Jul 8 Sacred Democracy-The Beatitudes of Fairness
- Jul 8 Speaking With a ‘Fractivist’: Data Acquisition to Federal Exemptions
- Jul 8 Selections from the Public News Service-July 2013 (Audio)
- Jul 8 How the Declaration of Independence got Hijacked
- Jun 10 A Bright Future: Creative, Passionate Students at Class Academy in Portland Participate in Read the Dirt Environmental Writing Contest
- Jun 8 (Audio): Read the Dirt’s Coverage of the 2013 Public Interest Environmental Law Conference
- Jun 8 Sacred Democracy-Living Democracy as Spiritual Practice (Or Vice Versa)
- May 8 Sacred Democracy-The Moral Blueprint
- May 8 Transforming Faith
- Feb 25 Park Rangers to the Rescue
- Feb 11 Washington’s Renewables: An Introduction
- Dec 12 Species Banks
- Nov 23 Our Slaves
- Nov 17 NW Coal Ports: Voice your concerns, voice them loud!
- Nov 13 Meditations on our Future
- Nov 4 Book: Ecoliterate: How Educators Are Cultivating Emotional, Social, and Ecological Intelligence
- Oct 14 Equity, Environmental Justice, and Industrial Pollution in Portland
- Oct 8 Cities advising Counties?
- Sep 12 Talking with Washington State Legislators-Stanford
- Aug 26 Talking with Washington State Legislators-Pollet
- Aug 21 Help! I’m being Climate Changed!
- Jul 14 Questionnaire for the authors of: THE GOLDILOCKS PLANET The 4 Billion Year Story of Earth’s Climate-Oxford University Press
- Jun 17 Can City Planning Make Us Cooler, Healthier and Friendlier?
- Jun 11 The Results-2012
- Mar 25 Making Clean Local Energy Accessible Now (Part 1)
- Mar 8 Our Right To Know
- Jan 18 PROTECT ONLINE FREEDOM—READ THE DIRT DEPENDS ON IT!
- Dec 23 Talking About Our Nuclear Hazard
- Oct 28 Why make Mt. St. Helens a National Park?
- Oct 20 The Story behind the Book, A Great Aridness: Climate Change and the Future of the American Southwest
- Jun 23 McKibben Comments on Expansion of Coal Exports at Cherry Point (Whatcom County)
- Apr 3 WASTED POWER
- Dec 20 Meet Some Environmental Consultants
- Dec 5 Using Dirt to Teach
- Oct 21 The We, The I and The Dirt
- Oct 21 Turning Pollution Into Energy
- Oct 21 Orange and Green
- Oct 21 Election 2010: Talk with a WA State Supreme Court Candidate (Wiggins)
- Oct 21 Election 2010: Talk with a WA State Supreme Court Candidate (Chief Justice Madsen)
- Oct 20 Our Dirty Web Designer (Video)